Antijudaísmo teológico en Gregorio Magno
Antijudaísmo teológico en Gregorio Magno
Sefarad
El uso de tópicos antijudíos por parte de los hombres de Iglesia del primer milenio ha suscitado debates en torno a las razones que motivaron tal práctica discursiva. Una línea de investigación enfatizó la existencia de un conflicto real entre judíos y cristianos, hecho que habría derivado en la constitución de la literatura Adversus Iudaeos. En contraste, otra posición hizo hincapié en aspectos discursivos, resaltando la necesidad cristiana de autodefinición en oposición a la matriz judía y confinando el antijudaísmo a cuestiones estrictamente textuales e identitarias distantes del contexto social inmediato. La figura de Gregorio Magno, gracias a la gran variabilidad textual que presenta su obra, otorga una herramienta fundamental a la hora de comprender las dinámicas del antijudaísmo cristiano. En este artículo se exploran todos los escritos gregorianos, mediante un estudio cualitativo y cuantitativo, poniéndose de releve en qué tipo de textos aparecen los topoi Adversus Iudaeos y concluyendo que, al menos para el Papa entre el 590 y el 604, el antijudaísmo fue una cuestión estrictamente simbólica.
The Christian use of anti-Jewish topics during the first millennium has generated discussions concerning the reasons for that discursive practice. Some researchers have considered a genuine conflict between Jews and Christians as the root of the Adversus Iudaeos literature. In contrast, another position emphasized discursive aspects, highlighting the Christian need for defining its identity in opposition to the Jewish past. From that point of view anti-Judaism thus stands as a textual question largely disconnected from the social context. The work of Gregory the Great, due to its noticeable textual variability, becomes a fundamental tool to understand the dynamics of anti-Judaism. In this article we explore all the Gregorian texts in a qualitative and quantitative analysis, underlining the kind of texts in which the topoi Adversus Iudaeos appear and concluding that, at least for the Pope between 590 and 604, anti-Judaism was a strictly symbolic question.
Bibliographic data
| Translated title: | Theological Anti-Judaism in Gregory the Great Rodrigo Laham Cohen |
|---|---|
| Journal Title: | Sefarad |
| Author: | Rodrigo Laham Cohen |
| Palabras clave: | |
| Traslated Keywords: | |
| Language: | Spanish |
| Get full text: | http://sefarad.revistas.csic.es/index.php/sefarad/article/view/717 |
| Resource type: | Journal Article |
| Source: | Sefarad; Vol 75, No 2 (Year 2015). |
| DOI: | http://dx.doi.org/10.3989/sefarad.015.008 |
| Publisher: | Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas CSIC |
| Usage rights: | Reconocimiento (by) |
| Categories: | Social Sciences/Humanities --> Religion |
Statistical data
- Views
- Consultations
- Citation style
- Share
- Export record
- Favourites
| Bibliography: | Adriaen, Marcus, ed. (1971):Gregorius Magnus. Homiliae in Hiezechihelem prophetam (CCSL 142 [Turnhout: Brepols]). Adriaen, Marcus, ed. (1979-1985): Gregorius Magnus. Moralia in Iob (CCSL 143, 143A y 143B [Turnhout: Brepols]). Bachrach, Bernard S. (1977): Early Medieval Jewish Policy in Western Europe (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press). Baltrusch, Ernst (1994): Gregor der Gro§e un sein VerhŠltnis zum Ršmischen Recht am Beispiel seiner Politik gegenuber den Juden, Historische Zeitschrift 259:1, 39-58. Bammel, Ernst (1991): Gregor der Grosse und die Juden, in Gregorio Magno e il suo tempo. XIX incontro di studiosi dell'antichitˆ cristiana in collaborazione con l'ƒcole Franaise de Rome. Roma, 9-12 maggio, 1990 (Roma: Institutum Patristicum Agustinianum) pp. 283-291. Banniard, Michel (1992): Viva voce. Communication écrite et communication orale du IVe au IXe sicle en Occident Latin (Paris: Brepols). Baron, Salo W. (1928): Ghetto and Emancipation: Shall We Revise the Traditional View?, Menorah 14, 515-526. Bartolomei Romagnoli, Alessandra (2003): Gregorio Magno davanti a Giobbe. Fondamenti di un'antropologia medievale, in Gilberto Marconi and Cristina Termini (eds.), I volti di Giobbe. Percorsi interdisciplinari (Bologna: EDB) pp. 127-145. Blumenkranz, Bernhard (1946): Die Judenpredigt Augustins. Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der judisch-christlichen Beziehungen in den ersten Jahrhunderten (Basel: Helbing & Lichtenhahn). Blumenkranz, Bernhard (1960): Juifs et Chrétiens dans le monde occidental, 430-1096 (Paris: Imprimerie Nationale). Blumenkranz, Bernhard (1963): Les auteurs chrétiens du Moyen Age sur les juifs et le juda•sme (Paris: Mouton). Boesch Gajano, Sofia (1979): Per una storia degli ebrei in Occidente tra Antichitˆ e Medioevo. La testimonianza di Gregorio Magno, Quaderni Medievali 8, 21-23. De Bonfils, Giovanni (1992): Gli schiavi dagli ebrei nella legislazione del IV secolo. Storia di un divieto (Bari: Cacucci). Borgen, Peder (1998): Proselytes, Conquest, and Missio, in P. Borgen, V. Robbins and D. Gowler (eds.), Recruitment, Conquest, and Conflict: Strategies on Judaism, Early Christianity and the Greco-Roman World (Atlanta: Scholars Press) pp. 57-77. Brown, Peter (2013): The Rise of Western Christendom. Triumph and Diversity, A.D. 200-1000 (Malden: Wiley-Blackwell). Calati, Benedetto (1991): Die Juden im Denken Gregors des Grossen. Bemerkungen zu Moralia in Job 35,26, Judaica 47:1, 31-37. Carleton Paget, James (1996): Jewish Proselytism at the Time of Christian Origins: Chimera or Reality?, Journal for the Study of the New Testament 62, 65-103. Castaldi, Lucia (2008): In librum primum Regum, in Giuseppe Cremascoli and Antonella Degl'Innocenti (eds.), Enciclopedia gregoriana: la vita, l'opera e la fortuna di Gregorio Magno (Firenze: Sismel) pp. 180-182. Clark, Francis (1987): The Pseudo-Gregorian Dialogues (Leiden: Brill). Clark, Francis (2003): The Gregorian Dialogues and the Origins of Benedectine Monasticism (Leiden-Boston: Brill). Cohen, Jeremy (1999): Living Letters of the Law: Ideas of the Jew in Medieval Christianity (Berkeley: University of california Press). Cohen, Shaye (1992): Was Judaism in Antiquity a Missionary Religion?, in Menachem Mor (ed.), Jewish Assimilation, Acculturation and Accommodation: Past Traditions, Current Issues and Future Prospects (Lanham: University Press of America). Colafemmina, Cesare (1980): Insediamenti e condizione degli ebrei nell'Italia meridionale e insulare, in Gli ebrei nell'alto medioevo. Settimane di Studio del Centro Italiano di Studi sull'Alto Medioevo, XXVI (Spoleto: Presso la sede del Centro) pp. 197-227. Colafemmina, Cesare (2003): Le catacombe ebraiche nell'Italia meridionale e nell'area s’cula: Venosa, Siracusa, Noto, Lipari e Malta, in Mauro Perani (ed.), I beni culturali ebraici in Italia: situazione attuale, problemi, prospettive e progetti per il futuro (Ravenna: Longo) pp. 119-146. Costamagna, Liliana (1991): La sinagoga di Bova Marina nel quadro degli insediamenti tardoantichi della costa Ionica meridionale della Calabria, Mélanges de l'Ecole franaise de Rome 103 (1991) pp. 611-631. Costamagna, Liliana (2003): La sinagoga di Bova Marina, in Mauro Perani (ed.), I beni culturali ebraici in Italia: situazione attuale, problemi, prospettive e progetti per il futuro (Ravenna: Longo) pp. 93-118. Cracco Ruggini, Lellia (1980): Pagani, ebrei e cristiani: odio sociologico e odio teologico nel mondo antico, in Gli ebrei nell'alto medioevo. Settimane di Studio del Centro Italiano di Studi sull'Alto Medioevo, XXVI (Spoleto: Presso la sede del Centro) pp. 15-101. Dagens, Claude (1977): Saint Grégoire le Grand. Culture et expérience chrétiennes (Paris: ƒtudes Augustiniennes). Dagens, Claude (1991): Saint Grégoire le Grand, Consul Dei, in Gregorio Magno e il suo tempo. XIX incontro di studiosi dell'antichitˆ cristiana in collaborazione con l'ƒcole Franaise de Rome. Roma, 9-12 maggio, 1990 (Roma: Institutum Patristicum Agustinianum) pp. 33-45. Dahan, Gilbert (1999): Les intellectuels chrétiens et les juifs au moyen ‰ge (Paris: ƒditions du Cerf). DelCogliano, Mark (2012): Gregory the Great. On the Song of the Songs (Kentucky: Cistercian Pubn). Dickson, John P. (2003): Mission-Commitment in Ancient Judaism and in the Pauline Communities: the Shape, Extent and Background of Early Christian Mission (Tubingen: Mohr Siebeck). Efroymson, David (1979): The Patristic Connection, in Alan T. Davies (ed.), Antisemitism and the Foundations of Christianity (New York: Paulist) pp. 98-117. Efroymson, David (1997): Review of M. Taylor, Anti-Judaism and Early Christian Identity: A Critique of the Scholarly Consensus JQR 87, 380-382. Engel, David (2006): Crisis and Lachrymosity: On Salo Baron, Neobaronianism, and the Study of Modern European Jewish History, Jewish History 20:3-4, 243-264. ƒtaix, Raymond, ed. (1999): Gregorius Magnus. Homiliae in Evangelia (CCSL 141 [Turnhout: Brepols]). Faller, Otto and Michaela Zelzer, eds. (1968-1990): Sancti Ambrosii opera (CSEL 82 [4 vols., Viena: Tempsky; Leipzig: Freytag]) pp. XX-XV. Feldman, Louis H. (1993): Jews and Gentile in the Ancient World (Princeton: University Press). Felle, Antonio Enrico Judaism and Christianity in the Light of Epigraphic Evidence (3rd-7th Cent. C.E.), Henoch 29:2, 354-377. Fredriksen, Paula (2008): Augustine and the Jews. A Christian defense of Jews and Judaism (New York: Doubleday). Fredrisken, Paula (2013): Roman Christianity and the Post-Roman West: The Social Correlates of the Contra Iudaeos Tradition, in Natelie Dohrmann and Annette Yoshiko Reed (eds.), Jews, Christians, and the Roman Empire. The Poetics of Power in Late Antiquity (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press) pp. 249-266. Fredrisken, Paula and Oded Irshai (2006): Christian anti-Judaism: Polemics and Policies, in Steven T. Katz (ed.), The Cambridge History of Judaism. Volume 4: The Late Roman-Rabbinic Period (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) pp. 977-1034. Gaston, Lloyd (1986): Retrospect, in Stephen G. Wilson (ed.), Anti-Judaism in Early Christianity. Volume 2: Separation and Polemic (Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier University Press) pp. 163-174. Goodman, Martin (1994): Mission and Conversion. Proselytizing in the Religious History of the Roman Empire (Oxford: Clarendon Press). Gšrres, Franz (1908): Papst Gregor I der Gro§e und das Judentum, Zeitschrift fu_r wissenschaftliche Theologie 50, 489-505. Graetz, Heinrich (1871): Geschichte der Juden... 5: vom Abschlu§ des Talmud (500) bis zum Aufbluhen der judisch-Spanischen Cultur (1027) (2» ed., Leipzig: Leiner). Harnack, Adolf von (1883): Die Altercatio Simonis Iudaei et Theophili Christiani, nebst Untersuchungen uber die antijudische Polemik in der alten Kirche, in Adolf von Harnack and Oscar von Gebhardt (eds.), Texte und Untersuchungen zur Geschichte der altchristlichen Literatur I:3 (Leipzig) pp. 1-136. Isaac, Jules (1948): Jésus et Isra‘l (Paris: Albin Michel). Isaac, Jules (1962): L'Enseignement du mépris : vérité historique et mythes théologiques (Paris: Fasquelle). Johnson, Luke (1989): The New Testament's Anti-Jewish Slander and the Conventions of Ancient Polemic, Journal of Biblical Literature 108, 419-441. Judic, Bruno, Floribert Rommel and Ch. Morel, eds. (1992): Grégoire le Grand. Rgle Pastorale (Paris: Les ƒditions du Cerf). Juster, Jean (1914): Les Juifs dans l'Empire Romain. Leur condition juridique, économique et sociale (Paris: Paul Geuthner). Katz, Solomon (1933): Pope Gregory the Great and the Jews, JQR 24, 113-136. Ladner, Gerhard B. (1971): Aspects of Patristic Anti-Judaism, Viator 2, 355-363. Laham Cohen, Rodrigo (2010): Pervivencias jud’as en la Pen’nsula It‡lica. La sinagoga de Bova Marina en el ocaso de la Antiguedad Tard’a, Claroscuro 9, 171-191. Laham Cohen, Rodrigo (2011): En torno a motivaciones y efectos del discurso antijud’o: el caso de los Moralia in Iob de Gregorio Magno, Polis 23, 115-151. Laham Cohen, Rodrigo (2011): Los jud’os en el Registrum epistularum de Gregorio Magno. El valor del rol social en la definici—n del otro, in Diana Arauz Mercado (ed.), Pasado, presente y porvenir de las humanidades y las artes III (Zacatecas: Texere Editores et alii) pp. 267-292. Laham Cohen, Rodrigo (2013): Los jud’os en el Registrum epistularum de Gregorio Magno y la epigraf’a jud’a de los siglos VI y VII, Henoch 35:2, 214-246. Laham Cohen, Rodrigo (in press): Vas uacuum et signatum. La Imagen del jud’o en los Dialogi y el problema de la autor’a gregoriana, Revue des ƒtudes Juives. Langmuir, Gavin (1971): Anti-Judaism as the Necessary Preparation for Anti-Semitism, Viator 2, 383-389. Le Goff, Jacque (1980): Le juif dans les exempla médiévaux: le cas de l'Alphabetum narrationum, in Maurice Olender (ed.), Le racisme. Mythes et sciences. Mélanges Léon Poliakov (Bruxelles: Complexe) pp. 209-220. Leiwo, Martti (2002): From contact to Mixture: Bilingual Inscriptions from Italy, in James Noel Adams, Mark Jansé and Simon Swain (eds.), Bilingualism in Ancient Society. Language Contact and Written World (Oxford: Oxford University Press) pp. 168-194. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199245062.003.0007 Levine, Lee I. (2005): The Ancient Synagogue. The First Thousand Years (2» ed., New Haven: Yale University Press). Linder, Amnon (1987): The Jews in Roman Imperial Legislation (Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1987). Lukyn Williams, Arthur (1935): Adversus Judaeos: A Bird's-Eye View of Christian Apologiae until the Renaissance (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). MacLennan, Robert S. (1990): Early Christian Texts on Jews and Judaism (Atlanta: Scholars Press). Makuja, Darius O. (2009): Gregory the Great, Roman Law and the Jews: Seeking 'true' Conversions, Sacris Erudiri 48, 35-76. Markus, Robert (1986): Gregory the Great's Rector and his Genesis, in Jacques Fontaine, Robert Gillet and Stan-Michel Pellistrandi (eds.), Grégoire le Grand. Actes du colloque international du CNRS, Chantilly, 15-19 septembre, 1982 (Paris: CNRS) pp. 137-146. Markus, Robert (1996): The Jew as a Hermeneutical Device: The Inner Life of a Gregorian Topos, in John C. Cavadini (ed.), Gregory the Great. A Symposium (Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1996) pp. 1-15. Markus, Robert (1997): Gregory the Great and his World (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). Martello, Fabrizio (2005): Il pubblico del predicatore nelle Homiliae in Hiezechihelem di Gregorio Magno, in Guido Innocenzo Gargano (ed.), L'ereditˆ spirituale di Gregorio Magno tra Occidente e Oriente. Atti del Simposio Internazionale Gregorio Magno 604-2004, Roma 10-12 marzo 2004 (Roma: Il Segno Gabrielli Editori) pp. 201-228. Massie, Alban (2011): Peuple Prophétique et nation témoin. Le peuple juif dans le Contra Faustum manichaeum de saint Augustin (Paris: Institut d'ƒtudes Augustiniennes). McKnight, Scot (1991): A Light among the Gentiles. Jewish Missionary Activity in the Second Temple Period (Minneapolis: Fortress Press). Mommsen, Theodor (1893): Die Bewirtschaftung der Kirchenguter unter Papst Gregor I, Zeitschrift fur Sozial- und Wirtschaftsgeschichte 1, 43-60. Morlet, Sébastien, Olivier Munnich and Bernard Pouderon, eds. (2013): Les dialogues 'adversus Iudaeos'. Permanences et mutations d'une tradition polémique. Actes du colloque international organisé les 7 et 8 décembre 2011 ˆ l'Université de Paris-Sorbonne (Turnhout: Brepols). Myers, David N. and William V. Rowe, eds. (1997): From Ghetto to Emancipation. Historical and Contemporary Reconsiderations of the Jewish Community (Scranton: University of Scranton Press). Neil, Bronwen and Matthew J. Dal Santo, eds. (2013): A Companion to Gregory the Great (Leiden-Boston: Brill). Norberg, Dag, ed. (1982): Gregorius Magnus. Registrum Epistularum (CCSL 140 and 140A [Turnhout: Brepols]). Noy, David (1993): Jewish Inscriptions of Western Europe. V. I: Italy (excluding the city of Rome), Spain and Gaul (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). Noy, David (1995): Jewish Inscriptions of Western Europe. V. II: Rome (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). Noy, David (1999): Jewish Inscriptions of Western Europe. Language and Community, in Atti dell'XI Congresso Internazionale di Epigrafia Greca e Latina (Roma: Edizioni Quasar) pp. 603-612. Pakter, Walter (1988): Medieval Canon Law and the Jews (Eblesbach: Rolf Gremer). Parente, Fausto (2001): Verus Israel di Marcel Simon a cinquant'anni dalla pubblicazione in C. Gianotto and G. Filoramo (eds.), Verus Israel (Brescia: Paideia) pp. 19-46. Parkes, James (1934): The Conflict of the Church and the Synagogue (London: Soncino Press). Pricoco Salvatore and Manlio Simonetti, eds. (2005-2006): Gregorio Magno. Storie di Santi e Diavoli (2 vols., Milano: Fondazione Lorenzo Valla-Mondadori). De Rossi, Giovanni Battista, ed. (1888): Inscriptiones Christianae Urbis Romae, 2:1 (Roma: Philippi Cuggiani). Ruether, Rosemary Radford (1974): Faith and Fratricide: The Theological Roots of Anti-Semitism (New York: Seabury Press). Serfass, Adam (2006): Slavery and Pope Gregory the Great, Journal of Early Christian Studies 14, 77-103. Simon, Marcel (1948): Verus Israel.Etude sur les relations entre chrétiens et juifs dans l'Empire Romain (135-425) (Paris: E. de Boccard). Stern, Jean (2000): Israel et l'eglise dans l'exegese de Saint Grégoire le Grand, in L'esegesi dei padri latini. Dalle Origini a Gregorio Magno (Roma: Institutum Patristicum Augustinianum) pp. 675-689. Stroumsa, Guy G. (1996): From Anti-Judaism to Antisemitism in Early Christianity?, in Ora Limor and Guy G. Stroumsa (eds.), Contra Iudaeos. Ancient and Medieval Polemics between Christians and Jews (Tubingen: Mohr Siebeck) pp. 1-26. Taylor, Miriam S. (1995): Anti-Judaism and Early Christian Identity. A Critique of the Scholarly Consensus (Leiden-New York-Cologne: Brill). Thesaurus Augustinianus (Turnhout: Brepols, 1989). Thesaurus Sancti Ambrosii (Turnhout: Brepols, 1994). Thesaurus Sancti Gregorii Magni (Turnhout: Brepols, 1986). Thesaurus Sancti Hieronymi (Turnhout: Brepols, 1990). Tiollier, Victor (1913): Saint Grégoire le Grand et les Juifs. Esquisse doctrinale et historique (Brignais: ƒcole professionnelle de Sacuny). Toch, Michael (2013): The Economic History of European Jews. Late Antiquity and Early Middle Ages (Leiden-Boston: Brill). Tromba, E., La sinagoga dei giudei in epoca romana: presenza ebraica a Reggio Calabria e provincia (Reggio Calabria 2001). Urbach, Ephraim E. (1979): The Laws regarding Slavery (New York: Arno Press). Verbraken, Patricius, ed. (1963): Gregorius Magnus. In Canticum canticorum. In Librum primum Regum (CCSL 144 [Turnhout: Brepols]). De Vogué, Adalbert (1996): L'Auteur du Commentaire des Rois attribué a saint Grégoire: un moine de Cava? , Revue Bénédictine 106, 319-331. De Vogué, Adalbert and Paul Antin, eds. (1978-1980): Grégoire le Grand. Dialogues (SC. 251, 260 y 265 [3 vols., Paris: Les ƒditions du Cerf]). Von Harnack, Adolf (1897): Lehrbuch der Dogmengeschichte, III (Freiburg-Leipzig-Tubingen: Mohr Siebeck). Ware, James Patrick (2005): The Mission of the Church in Paul's Letter to the Philippians in the Context of Ancient Judaism (Leiden: Brill). Will, Edouard and Claude Orrieux (1992): Proselitisme juif. Histoire d'une erreur? (Paris: Les Belles Lettres). Wilson, Stephen G. (1986): Marcion and the Jews, in Stephen G. Wilson (ed.), Anti-Judaism in Early Christianity. Volume 2: Separation and Polemic (Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier University Press) pp. 45-58. |
|---|